Page 2 of 2

Re: The winners

Posted: Tue Sep 06, 2011 2:20 pm
by SandyM
Trunky wrote:Sandy, I have your prizes and rosettes here, want to pick them up or shall I haul them to the next meeting?
I'll come pick them up, not sure if I can make it to the next meeting as I may be working that night. I'll text you.

Re: The winners

Posted: Tue Sep 06, 2011 7:15 pm
by Taz Ales
13 points for PJ & Duncan! What the hell?

Re: The winners

Posted: Tue Sep 06, 2011 7:21 pm
by alikocho
Taz Ales wrote:13 points for PJ & Duncan! What the hell?
I'd have thought that beer would Slam Dunk the Funk!

But seriously, there'll be feedback (it's all been sent out already after a late night session with an Imperial Stout so expect packets in the post). Read it. Taste the beer. Contact the judges if you want to.

It might also have been a bad bottle. The second (if asked for) may also have been bad.

Re: The winners

Posted: Tue Sep 06, 2011 7:22 pm
by alikocho
SandyM wrote:
Trunky wrote:Sandy, I have your prizes and rosettes here, want to pick them up or shall I haul them to the next meeting?
I'll come pick them up, not sure if I can make it to the next meeting as I may be working that night. I'll text you.
I have your feedback sheets, which I didn't post as I knew you were moving....

Re: The winners

Posted: Tue Sep 06, 2011 7:28 pm
by SandyM
alikocho wrote:
SandyM wrote:
Trunky wrote:Sandy, I have your prizes and rosettes here, want to pick them up or shall I haul them to the next meeting?
I'll come pick them up, not sure if I can make it to the next meeting as I may be working that night. I'll text you.
I have your feedback sheets, which I didn't post as I knew you were moving....
Cheers Ali. BBC is next week right? Think I can make it after all, thought it was the week after. Can you bring them along to that please?

Re: The winners

Posted: Wed Sep 07, 2011 12:27 am
by SandyM
Oh also, having just looked at my scores for the competition, is there any way of looking at what the other winners scored? Or is that totally confidential? I'm curious as I think it would be useful for comparison to get a gauge of how well we actually did.

Re: The winners

Posted: Wed Sep 07, 2011 8:04 am
by alikocho
SandyM wrote:Oh also, having just looked at my scores for the competition, is there any way of looking at what the other winners scored? Or is that totally confidential? I'm curious as I think it would be useful for comparison to get a gauge of how well we actually did.
It's confidential as to what others scored. You can gauge how well you did from the score you got and the feedback.

I can tell you that the range of scores accross categories was 0-45 - meaning that beers ranged from unsampleable to world-class style examples. The average score was 28. Worth remembering that different judges may have been more friendly or harsher than others, too.

Re: The winners

Posted: Wed Sep 07, 2011 8:24 am
by I_used_to_brew
Taz Ales wrote:13 points for PJ & Duncan! What the hell?
What category was that in?

Re: The winners

Posted: Wed Sep 07, 2011 6:23 pm
by Taz Ales
APA. I was going to stick it in as an English Pale, but you lot all said APA was closer to the mark.

Must have been something wrong, although all the other bottles of that have been fine.
Ho hum, never mind.